What is the church

Church Leadership

1 Timothy 3:1-2 · The church, the people of God

The New Testament gives the church leaders, chiefly elders (also called pastors or overseers) who shepherd and teach, and deacons who serve. Their qualifications in Scripture are mostly about character, not talent. Christian traditions order and name these offices differently, and we do not push one pattern. But all agree that church leaders are servants under one Shepherd, Jesus Christ, the true head of the church.

This is a true saying, If a man desire the office of a bishop, he desireth a good work. A bishop then must be blameless, the husband of one wife, vigilant, sober, of good behaviour, given to hospitality, apt to teach;1 Timothy 3:1-2 (KJV)

Elders, pastors, overseers

The New Testament describes leaders who guide and feed the church. It uses several words that overlap: elder, which speaks of maturity and wisdom; overseer or bishop, which speaks of watchful care; and pastor or shepherd, which speaks of feeding and protecting the flock. Writing to Timothy, Paul says that to desire the office of an overseer is to desire a good work, and then describes the kind of person fit for it.

What is striking is that the list is almost entirely about character. An overseer must be blameless, faithful in marriage, sober, gentle, hospitable, not greedy or quarrelsome, and able to teach. Only one item, the ability to teach, is a skill; the rest is who the person is. God entrusts his people to leaders proven not by charisma or success but by humble, tested godliness, because they are caring for souls Christ died for.

This is worth weighing whenever you consider a church. The world measures leaders by talent, confidence, and results, but Scripture measures them by character: are they gentle, self-controlled, honest, faithful at home, free from the love of money, patient with the difficult. A gifted leader without character is dangerous to a flock, while a leader of tested godliness, even a quiet one, is a gift. God cares far more about what a shepherd is than about how impressive he seems.

Deacons who serve

Alongside those who oversee and teach, the New Testament gives the church deacons, whose name means servant. The office seems to have begun when the apostles appointed trusted people to care for the practical needs of the church, so that the widows were not neglected and the word could keep going out. Paul tells Timothy that deacons too must be grave, sincere, honest, and tested, and that those who serve well gain a good standing and great boldness in the faith.

Deacons remind the whole church that leadership in the kingdom of God is service. The greatest, Jesus said, is the one who serves. The church is not run like a corporation with executives at the top, but like a household where those given authority use it to wash feet, meet needs, and build others up. Leadership that does not serve has forgotten the example of Christ, who came not to be served but to serve.

It matters, too, that the church's very first appointed leaders were put in charge of feeding the overlooked and making sure no one fell through the cracks. From the beginning, care for the vulnerable was not a side project but an office of the church. A congregation reveals what it truly is by how it treats its widows, its poor, its lonely, and its weak, and God gives the church servants precisely so that such people are seen and cared for in his name.

Traditions order it differently

Here honesty is important, and generosity too. Christians order church leadership in different ways. Some churches are led by bishops in an unbroken line of ordination. Some are governed by councils of elders. Some are led by a congregation that calls its own pastors. Some reserve these offices to men, others open them more widely. These differences are real, and sincere believers hold them from Scripture and conscience.

This cluster does not exist to settle those questions or to push one polity as the only right one. Good and faithful churches order themselves in each of these ways. If you are looking for a church home, it is worth understanding how a given tradition is led, and asking whether its leaders show the character Scripture calls for. But do not let the genuine variety trouble you, for beneath all of it stands one thing every tradition confesses.

It can actually steady your faith to know that Christians have loved and followed Jesus faithfully under each of these arrangements for centuries. The exact shape of church government is important and worth thinking through, but it was never meant to be the thing that divides you from Christ or from other believers. On the offices Scripture clearly gives, and the character it clearly requires, the whole church can stand together, even while ordering the details in different ways.

One Shepherd over every shepherd

However a church is governed, its leaders are undershepherds serving the one Chief Shepherd. Peter, himself an elder, urged the elders to feed the flock of God, not lording it over them but being examples, and promised that when the chief Shepherd appears they would receive a crown of glory. No pastor, priest, elder, or bishop is the head of the church. Christ alone is the head, and every leader answers to him for the souls in their care.

This is good news for the led and a sober charge to leaders. If you belong to a church, you are not finally in the hands of a fallible leader but in the hands of the Good Shepherd who lays down his life for the sheep. And leaders, however high their office, are servants who will give account to him. The church has one head, and his name is Jesus.

How to honor leaders without idolizing them

Scripture strikes a wise balance. It tells the church to respect and follow faithful leaders, to esteem them highly in love for their work's sake, and to make their labor a joy rather than a burden. Good shepherds are a real gift, and a healthy church honors them, prays for them, and receives their teaching gladly. To despise every authority is not humility; it is a kind of pride that leaves you unteachable.

But the same Scripture keeps leaders in their place: they are servants, not lords; examples, not masters of your faith. You are never asked to follow a leader against Christ or the clear word of God, and when leaders sin they are to be corrected, not shielded. The healthiest churches hold both together, honoring their shepherds while remembering that all of them, and all of us, belong to the one Shepherd who bought us with his blood and to whom every leader must give account.

For anyone weary of power and disappointed by leaders, this is quiet good news. The church at its healthiest is not built around a personality but around Christ, and its best leaders point away from themselves to him. When you look for a church home, you are not looking for a flawless leader, for there is none, but for humble servants who love Christ, handle his word with care, and treat the flock as people they will answer to God for. Such shepherds are a gift worth seeking, and behind them stands the one Shepherd whose love for you will never fail.

Across the traditions: Christian traditions order church leadership differently, by bishops, by elders, or by congregations, and they differ on who may hold each office. We present the offices as Scripture describes them and do not press one polity. What all traditions confess is that leaders are servants under Christ, the one head of the church.

An honest word: Church leaders are fallible, and some have abused their trust and wounded the very people they were meant to protect. Scripture takes such failure with deadly seriousness and holds leaders to account. Good leadership is real and worth seeking, and the failures of some do not cancel the gift of faithful shepherds who serve under Christ.

Related: The marks and mission of the church · What is the church · Find a church near you · What is the church